Cold Process Soap vs. Commercial Soap: What's the Difference?

Pick up a bar of soap at the grocery store and there's a good chance it isn't soap at all. Most of the bars on store shelves are synthetic detergents. Cold process soap is real soap, made from oils you can name, and it keeps its glycerin, which draws moisture to your skin. I'm a chemist by training, so let me show you what's really in each bar.

What Is Cold Process Soap?

Cold process is the traditional way to make soap from scratch. The oils are mixed with lye, and the only heat needed is to melt the base oils. The reaction does the rest.

That reaction is called saponification. Oils meet lye, and together they transform into soap and glycerin. When soap is made properly, no lye remains in the finished product. It has all turned into soap.

Then the bars rest. Cold process soap needs time to cure before it's ready to use. There's no rushing it, and that's part of what makes a handmade bar different.

Real Soap vs. Detergent: What's the Difference?

A detergent bar cleans with synthetic detergents instead of soap made from oils. Detergents make suds easily, which is why they're everywhere. They are just a different thing than real soap.

What's in Commercial Soap?

Here's the surprise. According to the FDA, very few true soaps are on the market today. Most body cleansers, both liquid and solid, are synthetic detergent products, and many of them are marketed as "soap" even though they don't meet the definition.

That's why so many store bars are called a "beauty bar" or a "cleansing bar."

What's in Our Cold Process Soap

You get a short list of ingredients you can actually pronounce. Our bars are made with organic sunflower oil, organic coconut oil and non-GMO organic soybean oil, plus pure essential oils, and sometimes clays, oatmeal or herbs. You'll find every ingredient listed on each soap page.

You also get to skip what you don't want on your skin. You'll never find palm oil, sodium lauryl sulfate, phthalates or parabens in our products. Our soap bars contain no animal products, and we're 100% cruelty free.

And every bar is made by hand by one of us at Good Earth, in Green Bay, Wisconsin. From weighing the ingredients to labeling each product, we do it all.

The Benefits of Handmade Cold Process Soap

Your skin keeps its moisture. Remember saponification? It makes glycerin right alongside the soap. In a cold process bar, that glycerin stays in the bar, and glycerin is a humectant, which means it draws moisture to your skin. It's a big part of why a good handmade bar feels so different from a detergent bar.

Rosemary Mint handmade soap bar made with organic oils

You get a bar made for what you need. Each batch has its own blend of essential oils and herbs. Rosemary Mint Soap is formulated to be extremely conditioning, which makes it an excellent facial bar.

Your nose gets the real thing. Most of our bars are scented with pure essential oils, like the Bulgarian lavender and lavender buds in our Lavender Soap.

The planet gets a break too. All of our products are biodegradable, and your order ships with zero plastic. Our Kitchen Kleen Soap even comes without a label, as a zero waste bar.

Handmade Soap Bars to Try

If you've only ever used store bars, here are a few good places to start:

  • Lemongrass Lavender Soap: our all time best seller. Earthy lemongrass touched with a hint of lavender for sweetness. If you've never tried our soap, this is the one for you.
  • Sweet Basil Vanilla Soap: rich, sweet and earthy, with glacial marine clay. One of our most popular scents.
  • Frankincense & Myrrh Soap: deeply meditative, an ancient scent revered for more than 5,000 years.

Frankincense and Myrrh handmade soap bar

You can see every scent in our handmade soap collection. Curious what "natural" and "organic" really mean on a soap label? I explain it in Natural vs. Organic Soap.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is cold process soap better than commercial soap?

For me, yes, without a doubt. A cold process bar is true soap made from plant oils, and it keeps its glycerin. Most commercial bars are detergents.

What is the difference between cold process soap and commercial soap?

Cold process soap is made by hand from oils and lye, then cured for weeks. Most commercial bars are synthetic detergent bars made to suds up fast.

Is there lye in cold process soap?

Lye is what turns oils into soap, but none is left in a properly made bar. By the time a bar is cured, it has all been turned into soap.

How can I tell if a bar is real soap or a detergent bar?

Read the label. Detergent bars are often called a "beauty bar" or a "cleansing bar." Then check the ingredients: real soap is made from oils, and a good maker will tell you exactly which ones.

Is your soap palm free?

Yes. Every bar we make is palm oil free. You can read why in Why Choose Palm-Free Soap?

Thank you for caring about what goes on your skin. We're making a difference one bar of soap at a time, and so are you. If you have a question I didn't answer here, please reach out. I read every message.

XO Tracy